Skip to main content

Public Procurement in Malta – Part 2

 

This 4-part series aims to explain the lifecycle of public procurement in Malta: from the initial planning of a tender, through publication and bidding, evaluation of offers and contract award, to the execution of the contract and its enforcement and litigious action.

Publication of the Tender and Bidding Stage

In Malta, tenders are published on the Electronic Public Procurement System (ePPS). Above EU thresholds, ePPS notices are also published in the Official Journal of the EU, opening participation EU-wide. Each tender notice (often called a Contract Notice) provides key information at a glance: the title and summary of the contract, the contracting authority’s name, the deadline for submission of bids, the CPV (Common Procurement Vocabulary) codes describing the contract type, whether the tender is divided into lots, the award method (e.g. lowest price or best price-quality ratio), and so on.

Alongside the notice, authorities issue the Procurement Documents (also known as the tender dossier). These typically include: Instructions to Tenderers (detailing how to submit a bid, timelines, and procedural rules), the Technical Specifications or Terms of Reference (explaining the requirements in detail), the Draft Contract (with terms and conditions that will govern the execution of the project or supply), and various forms and response templates that bidders must fill out (for example, forms for the bidder’s information, the European Single Procurement Document (ESPD) or a self-declaration for eligibility, technical offer forms, financial bid forms, and any model templates for guarantees or key staff CVs, etc.).

The tender will also indicate a submission deadline, which must comply with minimum time-limits set by law. In an open procedure (the most common method), typically bidders get around 35 to 40 days to submit their offers for above-threshold tenders, which can be shorter for national tenders or if certain urgency or prior publication conditions apply.

During this period, bidders may ask the contracting authority clarification questions. In Malta, the ePPS platform facilitates a Q&A process: bidders post queries, and the contracting authority issues Clarification Notes with answers or any necessary corrections to the tender documents. Importantly, any clarification or addendum is communicated to all prospective bidders (usually via the ePPS notification and publicly on the tender page) to maintain a level playing field. If a clarification significantly alters the tender requirements, the authority might also extend the submission deadline to give bidders time to adjust. By law, all these communications must uphold transparency and cannot change the fundamental nature of the contract, they are meant only to clarify or correct errors, not to introduce new substantial requirements mid-way.

Prospective bidders may file pre-contractual appeals with the Public Contracts Review Board in cases where they deem that there is something wrong with the tender documents or the procedure before the bid deadline, for example, a discriminatory specification, or an unlawful condition in the tender. This complaint must be filed with the Board within the first two-thirds of the tender period. The Board has the power to order the contracting authority to fix the issue (such as removing an unfair requirement, correcting an ambiguity, or even cancelling the tender if it’s irredeemably flawed) before bids are submitted. This mechanism ensures that obvious legal issues can be addressed early, rather than wasting everyone’s time.

Bid submission in Malta is fully electronic and at the deadline, the portal should lock out late submissions and allows the appointed officials to open the bids. In many cases, there is an electronic bid opening session where the names of bidders (and sometimes key bid values, like total price) are recorded. The entire publication and bidding stage is intended to be a structured process designed for fairness.

Evaluation and Award of Contract

Once bids are submitted, the process enters the evaluation phase. This is where the contracting authority examines the offers and awards the contract. Maltese procurement law, reflecting EU rules, mandates that the evaluation must strictly follow the criteria and methodology set out in the published tender documents, no surprises or changes of criteria are allowed at this stage. Typically, the authority appoints an Evaluation Committee, usually a small team of officials or experts, to review and score the bids. In some cases (especially high-value or complex tenders), independent technical experts or consultants might be part of the evaluation. There are also oversight committees in the Maltese system: for example, the Departmental Contracts Committee (DCC) that oversees smaller procurements, and the General Contracts Committee (GCC) at the Department of Contracts oversees larger ones. These committees often review the evaluation report and endorse the recommendation of the Evaluation Committee, which aims to add an extra layer of governance before final award.

The evaluation itself generally happens in several steps, ensuring all offers are assessed fairly:

  • Administrative Compliance Check: The committee verifies completeness of bids: forms, declarations, financial bids, guarantees. Minor clerical errors may be rectified, but no substantial changes can be made by bidders at this point, only obvious mistakes or missing formalities can be fixed within a short timeframe. Bids that lack fundamental requirements or that don’t meet eligibility criteria should be disqualified at this stage.
  • Technical Evaluation: Next, the evaluators assess each offer against specifications and quality criteria (e.g., methodology, work plan, personnel). Scores must be justified. Bids failing mandatory requirements are rejected. Only those offers that meet or exceed all minimum technical standards proceed further.
  • Financial Evaluation: Finally, financial bids are reviewed after technical checks. If lowest price is the criterion, the cheapest compliant bid is recommended. If based on best price-quality ratio, scores are combined using the published formula. In all cases, the evaluation must adhere exactly to the formula or rules published; the committee cannot introduce new factors or discretion beyond what was advertised.

Once the evaluation committee completes its assessment, it should compile an Evaluation Report documenting the process and its recommended outcome, which should be submitted for approval to the appropriate authority (e.g., the Departmental Contracts Committee of the ministry, or the General Contracts Committee at the Department of Contracts, depending on the tender). Upon approval, the contracting authority makes an Award Decision thereby selecting the winning bidder and establishing the intention to formally award them the contract.

The final step in the award phase is critical for transparency and fairness: notification of the outcome to all bidders and observing a standstill period. Maltese regulations (in line with EU Remedies Directive provisions) require that once a proposed award is decided, every participating bidder is informed of the decision before the contract is actually signed and given a brief period to challenge the outcome if they believe it was improper. Each bidder typically receives a letter (often via ePPS or email) stating who the proposed winner is and, for the losing bidders, the reasons why their offer was not selected. Crucially, the communication will also specify the length of the standstill period during which the contract will not be signed, giving aggrieved bidders the opportunity to file an appeal. In Malta, any tender above €5,000 in value is subject to this standstill and possible appeal mechanism, meaning virtually all but the smallest procurements have this safeguard.

If no appeal is lodged within the standstill period, the contracting authority can proceed to contract signing with the successful bidder. If an appeal is lodged, the regulations impose an automatic suspension of the award meaning that a contract doesn’t go forward if there’s a legitimate dispute about the award- it “freezes” until adjudicated.

 

AE Legal can assist you in navigating the procurement process from initial tender drafting to representation.

The above is intended for information purposes only and is not intended to act as legal advice.

Bernica Saliba

Bernice Saliba

bsaliba@ae.com.mt

Sean Cutajar

scutajar@ae.com.mt